london review of books ekşi

london review of books

• son 24 saat
• son 1 hafta

ekşi sözlük kullanıcılarıyla mesajlaşmak ve yazdıkları entry'leri takip etmek için giriş yapmalısın.

bu özelliği kullanmak için reklamsız üyeliğe sahip olmanız gerekmektedir. mobil uygulamamızı indirerek reklamsız aboneliğinizi başlatabilirsiniz.

Jump to navigation Skip to content

Search form

• P&W on Facebook
• P&W on Twitter
• P&W on Instagram

Find details about every creative writing competition—including poetry contests, short story competitions, essay contests, awards for novels, grants for translators, and more—that we’ve published in the Grants & Awards section of Poets & Writers Magazine during the past year. We carefully review the practices and policies of each contest before including it in the Writing Contests database, the most trusted resource for legitimate writing contests available anywhere.

Find a home for your poems, stories, essays, and reviews by researching the publications vetted by our editorial staff. In the Literary Magazines database you’ll find editorial policies, submission guidelines, contact information—everything you need to know before submitting your work to the publications that share your vision for your work.

Whether you’re pursuing the publication of your first book or your fifth, use the Small Presses database to research potential publishers, including submission guidelines, tips from the editors, contact information, and more.

Research more than one hundred agents who represent poets, fiction writers, and creative nonfiction writers, plus details about the kinds of books they’re interested in representing, their clients, and the best way to contact them.

Every week a new publishing professional shares advice, anecdotes, insights, and new ways of thinking about writing and the business of books.

Stay informed with reports from the world of writing contests, including news of extended deadlines, recent winners of notable awards, new contest announcements, interviews with winners, and more.

Find publishers ready to read your work now with our Open Reading Periods page, a continually updated resource listing all the literary magazines and small presses currently open for submissions.

Since our founding in 1970, Poets & Writers has served as an information clearinghouse of all matters related to writing. While the range of inquiries has been broad, common themes have emerged over time. Our Top Topics for Writers addresses the most popular and pressing issues, including literary agents, copyright, MFA programs, and self-publishing.

Our series of subject-based handbooks (PDF format; $4.99 each) provide information and advice from authors, literary agents, editors, and publishers. Now available: The Poets & Writers Guide to Publicity and Promotion, The Poets & Writers Guide to the Book Deal, The Poets & Writers Guide to Literary Agents, The Poets & Writers Guide to MFA Programs, and The Poets & Writers Guide to Writing Contests.

Find a home for your work by consulting our searchable databases of writing contests, literary magazines, small presses, literary agents, and more.

Poets & Writers lists readings, workshops, and other literary events held in cities across the country. Whether you are an author on book tour or the curator of a reading series, the Literary Events Calendar can help you find your audience.

Get the Word Out is a new publicity incubator for debut fiction writers and poets.

Research newspapers, magazines, websites, and other publications that consistently publish book reviews using the Review Outlets database, which includes information about publishing schedules, submission guidelines, fees, and more.

Well over ten thousand poets and writers maintain listings in this essential resource for writers interested in connecting with their peers, as well as editors, agents, and reading series coordinators looking for authors. Apply today to join the growing community of writers who stay in touch and informed using the Poets & Writers Directory.

Let the world know about your work by posting your events on our literary events calendar, apply to be included in our directory of writers, and more.

Find a writers group to join or create your own with Poets & Writers Groups. Everything you need to connect, communicate, and collaborate with other poets and writers—all in one place.

Find information about more than two hundred full- and low-residency programs in creative writing in our MFA Programs database, which includes details about deadlines, funding, class size, core faculty, and more. Also included is information about more than fifty MA and PhD programs.

Whether you are looking to meet up with fellow writers, agents, and editors, or trying to find the perfect environment to fuel your writing practice, the Conferences & Residencies is the essential resource for information about well over three hundred writing conferences, writers residencies, and literary festivals around the world.

Discover historical sites, independent bookstores, literary archives, writing centers, and writers spaces in cities across the country using the Literary Places database—the best starting point for any literary journey, whether it’s for research or inspiration.

Search for jobs in education, publishing, the arts, and more within our free, frequently updated job listings for writers and poets.

Establish new connections and enjoy the company of your peers using our searchable databases of MFA programs and writers retreats, apply to be included in our directory of writers, and more.

• Register for Classes

Each year the Readings & Workshops program provides support to hundreds of writers participating in literary readings and conducting writing workshops. Learn more about this program, our special events, projects, and supporters, and how to contact us.

The Maureen Egen Writers Exchange Award introduces emerging writers to the New York City literary community, providing them with a network for professional advancement.

Find information about how Poets & Writers provides support to hundreds of writers participating in literary readings and conducting writing workshops.

Bring the literary world to your door—at half the newsstand price. Available in print and digital editions, Poets & Writers Magazine is a must-have for writers who are serious about their craft.

View the contents and read select essays, articles, interviews, and profiles from the current issue of the award-winning Poets & Writers Magazine .

Read three decades of essays, articles, interviews, profiles, and other select content from Poets & Writers Magazine .

View the covers and contents of every issue of Poets & Writers Magazine , from the current edition all the way back to the first black-and-white issue in 1987.

In our weekly series of craft essays, some of the best and brightest minds in contemporary literature explore their craft in compact form, articulating their thoughts about creative obsessions and curiosities in a working notebook of lessons about the art of writing.

The Time Is Now offers weekly writing prompts in poetry, fiction, and creative nonfiction to help you stay committed to your writing practice throughout the year. Sign up to get The Time Is Now, as well as a weekly book recommendation for guidance and inspiration, delivered to your inbox.

Every week a new author shares books, art, music, writing prompts, films—anything and everything—that has inspired and shaped the creative process.

Watch videos, listen to audio clips, and view slideshows related to articles and features published in Poets & Writers Magazine .

Ads in Poets & Writers Magazine and on pw.org are the best ways to reach a readership of serious poets and literary prose writers. Our audience trusts our editorial content and looks to it, and to relevant advertising, for information and guidance.

Start, renew, or give a subscription to Poets & Writers Magazine ; change your address; check your account; pay your bill; report a missed issue; contact us.

Peruse paid listings of writing contests, conferences, workshops, editing services, calls for submissions, and more.

Poets & Writers is pleased to provide free subscriptions to Poets & Writers Magazine to award-winning young writers and to high school creative writing teachers for use in their classrooms.

Read select articles from the award-winning magazine and consult the most comprehensive listing of literary grants and awards, deadlines, and prizewinners available in print.

• Subscribe Now

London Review of Books

• Printable Version
• Log in to Send
• Log in to Save

Since 1979, London Review of Books has focused on protecting and promoting the tradition of the literary and intellectual essay in English. Each issue contains essays, book reviews, poems, an exhibition review, "short cuts," letters, and a diary. For book reviews, they look at both unsolicited submissions and proposals.

Contact Information

Stay in the loop and register for email updates about events, competitions and all things poetry.

sign up now

Global Search

Royal Festival Hall (Level 5), Southbank Centre, London Open Tuesday 12 noon - 6 pm, Wednesday to Sunday 12 noon – 8 pm

You are here

London review of books.

The LRB is Europe’s leading magazine of books and ideas. Published twice a month, it provides a space for some of the world’s best writers to explore a wide variety of subjects in exhilarating detail – from culture and politics to science and technology via history and philosophy. In the age of the long read, the LRB remains the pre-eminent exponent of the intellectual essay, admired around the world for its fearlessness, its range and its elegance.

Editor: Mary-Kay Wilmers

Visit website

How I used to love and now hate the London Review of Books

Speaking words of wisdom, LRB

I would read the London Review of Books from front to back. I had to read it all, from front to back. I couldn’t miss any part of what I then saw as the absolute requirement of reading the London Review of Books and absorbing all of the information contained in the London Review of Book s (excluding classifieds and incidental advertising about books, copywriters, book-based dating etc). 

I certainly couldn’t dip in and out of the London Review of Books . The London Review of Books told me, so I thought, everything that I needed to know. The best people would provide me with the best information about what I needed to know. It was a joy and my mind expanded and my taste developed and I became a refined intellectual.

I couldn’t read fast enough to keep up

This reading of each and every London Review of Books ended up making me very anxious ; or perhaps, my latent anxiety overwhelmed my joy of reading the London Review of Books . I couldn’t read fast enough to keep up with the bi-weekly production of these reviews of books.

I was reading nothing other than reviews of books in the London Review of Books . I had no remaining time to read the books they were reviews of, nor any other book. I no longer took any joy in the London Review of Books; it simply became a task or duty to read each copy before the next was delivered , and I began to skim read and hated myself for skim reading the London Review of Books , because I loved the London Review of Books .

Copies of the London Review of Books in their cellophane wrapping piled up , and I began to be frightened of them, frightened of the reading demands the London Review of Books was placing on me. 

Eventually I had to stop reading the London Review of Books , and the pile of London Review of Books filled a drawer which I kept entirely for the London Review of Books . I terminated my subscription because I could not accept reading the London Review of Books without reading it front to back (excluding classifieds , and incidental advertising etc). I couldn’t touch a copy for years , and refused offers from friends of their (used and filthy) copies of the London Review of Books ; those friends who couldn’t throw away their own copies due to the high status of the London Review of Books , and its high cost.

This year, after having said how I used to love and now hated the London Review of Books and couldn’t handle my subscription to it and would never want another one, my neighbour subscribed me behind my back and for free to the London Review of Books ; a free gift subscription . They were delivered to my home, now sealed in a paper envelope rather than the cellophane ( environmental responsibility ).

I opened the London Review of Books , the first I had opened for ten years , and prepared myself for a front to back read. I liked how folded it was , and how much better it was to read a fresh copy than the used (filthy) copies which had been pushed on me by friends who primarily wanted to indicate to me that they read the London Review of Books by offering their (used and filthy) copies  — thinking that I respected the London Review of Books and its users. 

I began reading and my attention wouldn’t hold. I skipped ahead and read half of one article, a line of another, a title of another. I tried to read the poetry and I still couldn’t understand a single line of it , and had no will to try.

Whereas before I could only think TJClarkPerryAndersonTariqAliNealAscherson thoughts, now I could think of no such London Review of Book thoughts, not even Mar iaWarnerJohnLanchesterJamesButlerAdam Mar sJones thoughts could enter my brain. My brain could take in no London Review of Books information , and could form no London Review of Books thoughts.

All this learning was in two dimensions

I considered what was wrong. Part of it was that every article was written in a this is how things are tone, all so tasteful and knowledgeable and clever. Yes, I knew that I would learn a lot, but it felt like all this learning was in two dimensions. It was a very narrow field. 

I considered: I had read the London Review of Books in order to belong to the LRB club and the knowledge I had wanted to acquire was wholly in order to become a member of this club. And the way the London Review of Books reviewers write — their style — is that of the self-assurance of a certain sort of group of people who are self-assured , or who want to write and be read among — and be among — those who are self-assured.

I reflected that England is one big private members club , and the LRB is just a part of this club (the letters “ LRB ” being a spoken code to enter that club). I discovered that this LRB club wasn’t in Bloomsbury, but in Hampstead , and I discovered that having been invited to play croquet on Hampstead Heath, in the Hampstead Heath Croquet Association, in which the words “elle are bee” occurred frequently.

I don’t want someone writing to me as if I were a member of their club , or want to be a member of their club. Everything in this country is a private members club, in which cordial agreement, shared references , and a shared picture of the world is required. A shared belief in what are the right views about the right subjects is required. These people — you? — know the facts and know how to pronounce the facts in the right way. Each article, each sentence of the LRB asks: are you a member of our club? aren’t you a member of our club? Club members look down from their vast knowledge, supported by the vast institutions of their education and the vast institutions of their working life. LRB is a performance of Englishness, just as much as the Hampstead Croquet Association is — often attracting performances by those most insecure in their Englishness.

I reject this LRB club and I will not become a member of it and nor will I cancel my free subscription to the London Review of Books .

Enjoying The Critic online? It's even better in print

Try five issues of Britain’s newest magazine for £10

• English Literature
• London Review of Books
• Subscription

What to read next

Is the English Lit degree killing love for literature?

Alexander Larman and Graham Stewart discuss the direction of English Literature at universities

Democracy without a demos

We have to overcome post-1989 illusions

The ascent of Barbara Pym   

A chronicler of the overlooked, she has at last got her just literary deserts

Pseudoscience exacerbates the burden of disease

Victims of ME deserve better than dopey Dragons and ear seeds

A serious accusation should be treated with appropriate seriousness

War on Nazis in Oz and in the air

LeBor reviews Our Dad the Nazi Killer and Masters of the Air

Train lines to nowhere

The farcical naming of new overground lines has exposed the fragility of progressivism

Survivors of male violence need single-sex spaces

Single-sex spaces and services are essential to the dignity and safety of female victims of male violence

Italian lessons

On matching the sauce to the pasta

The menopause is no joke

It is time to stop being so facetious about women’s health

Leaving Kindland, entering reality

“Being kind” at the expense of truth and reason can make us nothing of the kind

The ongoing fiasco of European defence

Starry-eyed talk of continental cooperation obscures the grim reality of competing interests

Fear the Keir

Starmer is Blair 2.0 — but this time, things can only get worse

The Conservatives face an extinction level election, but there’s still time for some prehistoric bloodletting

This is one of your 3 free articles without registering

For full access, subscribe to The Critic for less than £3 per month.

Already have an account? Log in .

SUBSCRIBE REGISTER FREE

You've reached the end!

Don't worry.

You can register for free to read Artillery Row articles.

Or get full access to The Critic for as little as £3 per month.

REGISTER FREE SUBSCRIBE

Premium access only.

Don't worry. You can continue reading by subscribing to get full access.

• Latest Posts
• LSE Authors
• Choose a Book for Review
• Submit a Book for Review
• Bookshop Guides

LSE RB Editor

December 16th, 2021, lse rb year in review: 12 most-read book reviews of 2021.

0 comments | 17 shares

Estimated reading time: 10 minutes

What were you reading in 2021 on LSE Review of Books? We count down the top 12 most-read new book reviews published in 2021 on the blog.

12.   Being Well in Academia: Ways to Feel Stronger, Safer and More Connected.  Petra Boynton. Routledge. 2020. 

Petra Boynton provides a practical guide on how to recognise and confront the various issues that can arise from being in academia. Chris Featherstone welcomed the book  for offering a succinct overview of the challenges that can be thrown at those studying or working in academia and a useful toolkit for addressing them.

11.  New Pandemics, Old Politics: Two Hundred Years of War on Disease and its Alternatives . Alex de Waal. Polity. 2021.

Alex de Waal offers a new political history of epidemics, identifying and critiquing a repeated mobilisation of the ‘war metaphor’ of pandemic disease to show our persistent (mis-)framing of biological illness. Hannah Farrimond found the book an extremely comprehensive and fascinating history of previous epidemics, their metaphors and manifestations, and a highly thought-provoking read in our current times.

10.  Decolonizing Politics: An Introduction . Robbie Shilliam. Polity. 2021.

Robbie Shilliam explores the colonial and racist logics enfolded within the history of political thought while also identifying decolonising moves within the discipline.  Sudhir Chella Rajan wrote that the book is infused with new possibilities and optimism, providing practical solutions for scholars keen to go beyond power-laden racialised and gendered categories of thinking.

9.  The Pay Off: How Changing the Way We Pay Changes Everything.  Gottfried Leibbrandt and Natasha de Terán. Elliott & Thompson Ltd. 2021.

Gottfried Leibbrandt and Natasha de Terán offer a new account of the history and workings of payments infrastructures, showing how the movement of money is crucial to understanding financial power today.  Martin C. W. Walker deemed the book  an essential first step for those looking to understand the possible future of the payments industry and its impact on the global economy.

8. They Were Her Property: White Women as Slave Owners in the American South.  Stephanie E. Jones-Rogers. Yale University Press. 2019.

Stephanie E. Jones-Rogers challenges the idea that white women were passive bystanders to the slave economy in the US, instead demonstrating their active participation in its structures of brutality and exploitation. Compellingly written and centring the testimonies of formerly enslaved people,  this award-winning book was praised by Ben Margulies  for offering an important contribution to both historiography and understandings of contemporary politics.

7.  How China Escaped Shock Therapy: The Market Reform Debate.  Isabella M. Weber. Routledge. 2021.

Isabella M. Weber explores the contestations behind China’s path to economic reform, showing how it committed to ‘experimental gradualism’ rather than the shock therapy of immediate market liberalisation.  George Hong Jiang found that this meticulous and wide-reaching book sheds light on the history of marketisation reforms in China and the factors that led it to escape shock therapy.

6. China’s Gilded Age: The Paradox of Economic Boom and Vast Corruption . Yuen Yuen Ang. Cambridge University Press. 2020.

Yuen Yuen Ang examines China’s growth trajectory through the prism of corruption, challenging the notion of Chinese exceptionalism when it comes to corruption by comparing its rise to the growth of the US in the nineteenth century. In a review translated into Spanish, Chinese and Vietnamese, Diego Castañeda Garza anticipated that the book will encourage readers to look beyond the cliches surrounding corruption by offering a comprehensive framework for studying the political economy of inequality and development.

5.   Leaving Academia: A Practical Guide . Christopher L. Caterine. Princeton University Press. 2020.

Christopher L. Caterine provides practical advice for those in academia who are considering changing careers.  Eryk Walczak recommended this book as a great read for both early-stage PhD students who might want to prepare a Plan B and more seasoned academics considering working in non-academic roles.

4. The War on the Uyghurs: China’s Campaign Against Xinjiang’s Muslims . Sean R. Roberts. Manchester University Press. 2020.

Sean R. Roberts offers a new account exploring how the US-led global ‘War on Terror’ has been used by China as a cover for the persecution of the predominantly Muslim Uyghur population.  Charles Dunst recommended the book as an empathetic and deeply informative work for those hoping to understand the humanitarian crisis in Xinjiang.

3. Out of the Dark Night: Essays on Decolonization . Achille Mbembe (trans. by Daniela Ginsburg). Columbia University Press. 2021.

Achille Mbembe offers a new collection exploring the complexities of decolonisation, intervening in debates about French democracy, African modernity, the aspirations of postcolonial thought and the possibilities of imagining community on a planetary scale.  Ayça Çubukçu reviewed this poetic and consistently erudite work , exploring the vision of humanity that Mbembe imagines across the collection.

2.  Empireland: How Imperialism Has Shaped Modern Britain . Sathnam Sanghera. Viking. 2021.

Sathnam Sanghera offers a new critique of the history of the British Empire and its continuing impact on British society, drawing on secondary source material, personal experience and sharp enquiry.  Ramnik Shah found this candid and informed book  to be deserving of all the plaudits heaped on it.

1. Humankind: A Hopeful History . Rutger Bregman. Bloomsbury. 2020.

Rutger Bregman takes the reader on a journey that dismantles the assumptions of classic research on human nature that positions humans as self-interested, instead exploring how humans can use our inherently good nature to build a better society. In the most-read new review of 2021 on LSE Review of Books, Rosie Hamilton welcomed the book’s perspective for offering a genuinely optimistic alternative that encourages readers to view the world from a different angle.

Note: The reviews in this reading list give the views of the authors, and not the position of the LSE Review of Books blog, or of the London School of Economics.

Banner Image Credit: Pixabay CCO .

Main Image Credit: Pixabay CCO .

About the author

This post was compiled by the LSE RB editor.

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Related posts.

15 Recommended LGBTQ+ Books for #IDAHOBIT2021

May 17th, 2021.

8 of the best books of 2020 recommended by LSE blog editors

December 17th, 2020.

LSE RB Year in Review: 12 Most-Read Book Reviews of 2020

December 16th, 2020.

Book Review: Humankind: A Hopeful History by Rutger Bregman

February 11th, 2021, subscribe via email.

Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Email Address

• TV & radio
• Art & design

London Review of Books editor Mary-Kay Wilmers steps down after 30 years

• Newspapers & magazines

London Review of Books - Subscribe to the LROB at the Lowest Rate Online!

1 hr 19 min

The Shoah After Gaza / Pankaj Mishra This Is Hell!

Pankaj Mishra discusses his London Review of Books article, "The Shoah After Gaza." Check out Pankaj's article here: https://www.lrb.co.uk/the-paper/v46/n06/pankaj-mishra/the-shoah-after-gaza Help keep This Is Hell! completely listener supported and access weekly bonus episodes by subscribing to our Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/thisishell

• More Episodes
• All rights reserved

Top Podcasts In News

LRB Blankets

Wool picnic blankets, as seen in new york magazine, tea or coffee.

Featured product

Rainbow stripe waterproof picnic blanket with straps – with the british blanket company.

We have partnered with the British Blanket Company to commission a range of picnic blankets for the LRB Store.

100% wool with waterproof polyester back and leather straps.

Size: 145 cm x 183 cm    

Wash : Machine wash cold on a specialist wool cycle. Do not spin. Use mild detergent recommended for wool. Wash separately to avoid snagging. Dry : Remove from machine promptly. Reshape whilst damp, do not wring. Line dry or dry flat ensuring even weight distribution. Do not tumble dry. Maintain : Remove shedding fibres with a lint roller. Pilling (bobbles) may form in areas of friction and can be removed with a pilling comb. Loose fibres and pilling will reduce after first wash. Not recommended for areas of high wear.

Shop By Product Type

• Canvas Bags
• Binders, Calendars and Diaries
• LRB Selections
• LRB Collections
• Back Issues & Cover Prints
• London Review of Books Subscription

The  London Review of Books  is the perfect magazine for anyone interested in history, politics, literature or the arts. Make sure you subscribe today.

One Hundred Books for the Next Twenty Years

To mark the twentieth anniversary of the London Review Bookshop, we invited twenty writers close to our hearts to choose the five books they think we need to navigate the  next  twenty years.

About the LRB Store

The  London Review of Books   is Europe’s leading magazine of culture and ideas. Published twice a month, it provides a space for some of the world’s best writers to explore a wide variety of subjects in exhilarating detail – from art and politics to science and technology via history and philosophy, not to mention fiction and poetry. In the age of the long read, the LRB remains the pre-eminent exponent of the intellectual essay, admired around the world for its fearlessness, its range and its elegance.

The LRB Store is a new initiative to meet demand, from readers and fans around the world, for authentic  London Review of Books merchandise.

Before now, all of these products were exclusively available from the London Review Bookshop . We wanted to make them available to customers unable to travel to London – although we hope you’ll still pay us a visit, next time you have an opportunity to do so.

• choosing a selection results in a full page refresh

London Review Bookshop

• Podcasts & video

Iain Sinclair’s Pariah Genius

Pre-order your signed copy and get a ​ Pariah Genius  tote bag and exclusive John Deakin postcard

Our Current Bestsellers

The rising down, alexandra harris, £25.00, white nights, urszula honek, £12.99, who's afraid of gender, judith butler, the silver bone, andrei kurkov, £20.00, the rebel's clinic, love's work, gillian rose, £9.99, minor detail, adania shibli, £10.99, a philosophy of walking, frédéric gros, sisters come second, lrb collections, £5.99, nora ephron, book of the week.

A luminous feat of time travel chronicling lives in a Sussex landscape from the prize-winning author of  Romantic Moderns  and  Weatherland .

The International Booker Prize 2024 Longlist

Rodrigo blanco calderón, not a river, selva almada, £11.99, undiscovered, gabriela wiener, £14.99, hwang sok-yong, £16.99, what i'd rather not think about, jente posthuma, crooked plow, itamar viera junior, the house on via gemito, domenico starnone, £15.99, veronica raimo, a dictator calls, ismail kadare, jenny erpenbeck, the details, london’s best independent bookshop.

Find out more about us

OPENING HOURS

Mon to Sat 10 am – 6:30 pm Sun 12 pm – 6 pm

EASTER WEEKEND

We will be closed for our annual stocktake and the Easter weekend, Wednesday 27 March to Monday 1 April inclusive

14 Bury Place London WC1A 2JL

+44 (0) 20 7269 9030

Plan your visit

Need a recommendation?

Ask our booksellers

Think Different

Subscribe to the LRB – perfect for anyone with an interest in history, politics, literature and the arts.

Author of the Month: Cixin Liu

The three-body problem, the dark forest, death's end, ball lightning, £8.99, the supernova era, hold up the sky, of ants and dinosaurs, the wandering earth, cixin liu's the village teacher, xiaoyu zhang, cixin liu's the wandering earth, christophe bec, cixin liu's yuanyuan's bubbles, valérie manguin, cixin liu's sea of dreams, podcasts & video.

Adam Phillips & Hermione Lee: On Giving Up

Lara Pawson & Jennifer Hodgson: Spent Light

Lavinia Greenlaw & Jennifer Higgie: The Vast Extent

Winner of the writers’ prize 2024, the home child, from £9.99.

Inspired by a true story, The Home Child is a beautiful novel-in-verse about a child far from home

Which side were you on?

Backbone of the nation, robert gildea, in loving memory of work, craig oldham, £32.00, andrew mcmillan, the underground sea, john berger, david peace, jeremy paxman, dragged up proppa, latest from the blog.

‘What a world. What a court.’: CHEERIO Director Harriet Vyner on Iain Sinclair’s ‘Pariah Genius’

An extract from Helen Garner’s ‘The Children’s Bach’

A Q&A with Liz Berry, winner of the Writers’ Prize 2024

The cake shop.

Honest food, inquisitive flavours and seasonal ingredients handmade for you, by us. Delivery now available.

Discover more

Signed editions

Bite your friends, fernanda eberstadt, £18.99, the children's bach, helen garner, monkey grip, this house of grief, alba arikha, cynthia zarin, £6.99, £15.00, revolutionary acts, jason okundaye, the new life, grow where they fall, michael donkor, pariah genius, iain sinclair, £19.99, alphabetical diaries, sheila heti, no judgement, lauren oyler, the creative act, run and hide, pankaj mishra, from the ruins of empire, age of anger, where we come from, aniefiok ekpoudom, come and get it, rural hours, harriet baker, jay bernard, mary jean chan, will harris, nisha ramayya, £12.00, sinéad gleeson, saraid de silva, the hypocrite, the future of songwriting, kristin hersh.

• Podcasts & Videos
• Newsletters

London Review of Books

More search Options

• Advanced search
• Search by contributor
• Browse our cover archive

Browse by Subject

• Arts & Culture
• Biography & Memoir
• History & Classics
• Literature & Criticism
• Philosophy & Law
• Politics & Economics
• Psychology & Anthropology
• Science & Technology
• Latest Issue
• Contributors
• About the LRB
• Close Readings

Leaving Haiti

Pooja bhatia.

Please sign in to read the full article.

O n ​ 2 March , armed men broke into two prisons in the Haitian capital, Port-au-Prince, and released almost five thousand inmates. The ratatatat of automatic gunfire sounded continuously throughout the city as the gangs torched buildings and had firefights with police. The US embassy, which since 2018 has warned Americans not to travel to Haiti, sent an email strongly advising its citizens to depart immediately by ‘commercial or other privately available transportation options’. But there were no options: gangs had taken the airport and controlled the major highways; the border with the Dominican Republic was closed. The unelected prime minister, Ariel Henry, in post since the assassination of Jovenel Moïse in 2021, was in Kenya, where he had flown a few days earlier to negotiate the deployment of a ‘multinational security support force’. No one wanted him back. Even the president of the Dominican Republic refused to allow him to use Hispaniola’s airspace. ‘I don’t know what they’re fighting over,’ my friend A. said a few days later, during a lull in the shooting. By then gangs had laid siege to the ports and ransacked hospitals and businesses. ‘There’s nothing left here.’

The US Coastguard has reported no increase in attempted crossings so far, but Republicans quickly seized on fears of a Haitian exodus. ‘What American didn’t get here somehow?’ the Haitian poet Félix Morisseau-Leroy wrote in 1991. ‘But it’s us they call boat people.’ That year, tens of thousands of Haitians took to the sea following the CIA-aided coup that removed the country’s first democratically elected leader, Jean-Bertrand Aristide. After the 2010 earthquake, and the subsequent electoral fiasco that brought Michel Martelly to power, Haitians again gave up on their country. They emigrated not just to the US or Canada, but to Brazil and later Chile, whose economies were booming. Their welcome was temporary. In 2015, for the first time, large numbers of Haitians made the seven-thousand-mile journey through South and Central America, and then north through Mexico to the US border. Some sought asylum. But most were simply ‘chèche lavi’ – looking for life.

In September last year, I visited a migrant encampment in Reynosa, a border town in northeastern Mexico. It was boiling hot and the dingy wall enclosing the encampment glowed white in the sun. Few of the places where people wait to cross the US-Mexico border are comfortable, but this one was especially bad. There were no toilets, no running water and no protection from rain, wind or sun. There was rubbish everywhere; it wasn’t easy to tell what was garbage and what might still be in use. Near the entrance to the camp was a small table where men played dominoes. Behind it hung various repurposed pieces of fabric: a street banner advertising beer; a child’s bedspread; a serape in blue and white. Twenty or so of the camp’s residents were crammed within the sliver of shadow provided by these remnants. They stood with arms crossed or sat on overturned buckets. All were Haitians who hoped to find a better life in the US. They had gathered to be told about the ways they were likely to be thwarted.

The speaker was Nicole Phillips, a lawyer for an American advocacy group called the Haitian Bridge Alliance. She wore a baseball cap and an aid-worker apron with the Kreyòl translation of ‘Many hands make light work’ printed on it. Gaining entry at the US’s southwest border has become incredibly complicated. Each of the 48 crossing posts has its own rules, which change often and are arbitrarily enforced. The language – not only around immigration law and asylum but also process and protocol – is opaque and at times seems intended to confuse. Washington politics, and in particular the spectre of Donald Trump, loom large.

In February, Trump exerted his influence to scupper a bipartisan deal that, among other restrictions, would have enabled the president to ‘shut down’ the border if the number of migrant encounters exceeded certain thresholds. Perhaps the bill wasn’t harsh enough for him. More likely, a ‘secure’ border is not in his interest ahead of the election: he wants voters to fear an invasion from the Global South – ‘shithole countries’, as he called them in 2018. As president, Trump tried to end Temporary Protected Status for victims of disasters in Haiti and several other countries, and used the pandemic to invoke a statutory provision, Title 42, which all but eliminated asylum claims. It took Biden more than two years to lift it, but for most of 2023 his border regime was comparatively humane to Haitians. Around 126,000 of them were able to secure individual sponsors, allowing them to reside in the US for two years. At least 67,000 more have been ‘paroled’ into the United States from the southwest border, declaring an intent to seek asylum, and given a notice to appear at deportation hearings. In total, this amounts to almost 2 per cent of the Haitian population.

Nicole tried to convey two main points to her audience in Reynosa. First, don’t cross until you have an appointment for inspection at a port of entry. Last spring, the government agency Customs and Border Protection launched a smartphone app, CBP One, which would-be migrants are supposed to use to book these inspections. The app is glitchy, but, as Nicole said, Haitians had been getting appointments in Reynosa. Keep trying, she said. Be patient. If you cross with an appointment, you are more likely to be paroled into the US and allowed to make your case for asylum, although the hearing may be some years away. Crossing without an appointment, by wading or swimming across the Rio Grande and turning yourself in to Border Patrol, makes asylum almost impossible. It is also to risk immediate removal and a five-year ban on crossing again.

Second, Nicole said, you must understand what it means to be an asylum seeker, someone fleeing persecution, with all the special protections that entails, versus an economic migrant, who has no protection. In Haiti, it’s hard to separate the political from the economic. Political leaders have armed and empowered gangs, which terrorise the population and make it impossible to engage in normal economic behaviour, such as going to work or saving money. American asylum law doesn’t protect people fleeing general violence and extortion. If asked during your appointment why you want to come to the United States, Nicole said, it’s best to emphasise your fear of returning to Haiti rather than the hopes you have of a better life in America. ‘Is anyone here not scared to return to Haiti?’ she asked. There was silence followed by laughter. ‘They killed the president in his bedroom!’ someone called out.

The camp itself was in a dangerous neighbourhood of Reynosa. Nicole and I had been told to be ready to make a ‘hard out’ in the event of gunfire or reports of cartel trouble. Smuggling groups have made a business out of helping migrants cross the Rio Grande and are not keen on competitors. If we got the signal we would flee in our car, perhaps sheltering in a nearby superstore if we couldn’t cross the bridge. The migrants had many fewer options.

When the meeting was over, I introduced myself to one of the women. M. had been a market seller in Gonaïves, a city about sixty miles north of Port-au-Prince. Over the years she expanded her business and became a successful vendor of various foodstuffs – garlic, salted herring, tomato sauce, bouillon cubes. Margins were small, so she relied on high-interest loans to finance her wholesale purchases, borrowing at rates of 40 per cent or more, with extra fees for late payments.

For many years M. left home before dawn on buying trips, arriving at the Port-au-Prince market of Croix-des-Bossales (the name of the 18th-century slave market that once operated there) by 8 a.m., and returning to Gonaïves before lunchtime. But by 2017, the journey had become difficult. Moïse was inaugurated in February following one botched election and another barely credible one, at which only 20 per cent of voters turned out. There were sometimes roadblocks on Route Nationale 1, the main highway from the north of Haiti to the capital, and often gunfire. If she had to buy stock, M. made herself go to the city ‘no matter what’. She had loans to repay. Even after her friend Odette was shot in the eye and killed during a market trip, M. felt the risk was necessary. She had nothing to do with gangs and was well known. She thought this would afford her some protection.

One morning in the summer of 2017 she got off the bus in Port-au-Prince and was set on by a group of men. ‘They beat me,’ she said. ‘There was a man behind me. He hit me from behind.’ Another assailant hit her knees with something sharp, like a shiv. Someone held a gun to her head. She had her cash, about $770, in a sachet in her bra and tried to tell them just to take it, but the men were attacking her so fiercely she couldn’t make herself heard.

M. was badly hurt, but managed to get home to Gonaïves, where she hid out; she was now badly in debt. Prosecutors wanted her to testify against her assailants. A juge d’instruction called to persuade her. ‘I told the judge, how would I know what they look like? I don’t even live in Port-au-Prince, and they came up behind me, I never saw their faces.’ If M., a ‘gwo marchann’ whom everyone knew, identified the bandits in a court of law, she would face retribution. She knew that even before the driver of the bus she had been on was killed. ‘There is no way there would be justice,’ she told me. ‘This was Haiti, a place where they shot the president in his own house, where they leave the ti malere , the weakest of the unfortunates, to die on the street.’ M. sold everything she had to pay back the loan. Her brother bought her a plane ticket and on 18 July 2017, she flew from the Dominican Republic to Chile. She was granted a visa on arrival and found work picking apples. She learned Spanish, met the man who would become her husband and for a short time had a new life.

M. might have a decent case for asylum in the US, Nicole told me, if she had evidence for her claims and framed her story the right way. She would need to convince the judge that the violence she suffered and feared was neither random nor general. Few Haitians who press their claims in court win asylum: 20 to 30 per cent historically, dropping under 10 per cent during the Trump era.

Even before last month’s collapse, many Haitians were describing their country as ‘fini’. ‘Pa gen peyi d’Ayiti anko’ is the refrain: ‘There is no country of Haiti anymore.’ In Tijuana, I met a 43-year-old accountant who used to work for a large Haitian company. It shut down after gangs threatened the owners. He sent his wife and small children out of Port-au-Prince for their safety but was unable to visit because gangs had taken over the highways. It was a double bind, he said: if you could afford to pay the ‘tax’ demanded at checkpoints, you would probably be a good kidnapping target.

US asylum law favours those persecuted because of identity or ideology, rather than those whose lives are made impossible by state failure or criminality. To ‘chèche lavi’ sounds like economic behaviour. Of course, the reasons Haitians must search for a livelihood, and a life, elsewhere, are political at every level. The US has played a decisive role in Haiti’s collapse. One proximate cause: its outlandish intervention in Haiti’s 2010 election, where aid was made conditional on the result. Jake Johnston’s new book, Aid State: Elite Panic, Disaster Capitalism and the Battle to Control Haiti (St Martin’s Press, £24.99), analyses America’s sordid manipulation of that election, which brought the corrupt – but pro-US – Martelly to power, as well as the 2016 election of Moïse, Martelly’s chosen successor. At the time of Moïse’s assassination in 2021, there were only ten elected officials in Haiti. For more than thirty months after that, and despite thoroughgoing Haitian opposition, Washington supported the leadership of Ariel Henry. That support ended only when his return to Haiti was prevented last month.

Two months after Moïse’s assassination, Americans were shocked by images from Del Rio, Texas, where fifteen thousand Haitian asylum seekers spent weeks living outdoors, waiting for inspection. One photograph showed a Border Patrol officer on horseback chasing a group of men. Instead of supporting a democratic transition in Haiti, or securing overdue legislative reform at home, the Biden administration has fudged its migration policies to permit hundreds of thousands of Haitians to come or remain in the US with liminal status. It is poor recompense. Haitians have hardly failed to notice that they are being forced to seek refuge in the country that has made their own unliveable. Biden’s more generous immigration policies have also ironically helped to reduce the alternatives to Henry, because so many opposition leaders have fled.

I met D. at an outdoor shelter in the Mexican city of Matamoros, 55 miles east of Reynosa. It was another blazingly hot day, but the shelter was large, orderly and clean, with identical green and white tents laid out in neat grids. A huge metal awning provided shelter. One wing was mostly occupied by Venezuelans. The other, smaller wing was Haitian.

Things had gone well for D. He had scored a place in the shelter and had managed to book an appointment on the CBP One app almost immediately. His inspection was scheduled for the next day. Although his passport was Haitian, he had been rendered stateless for much of his life. He was born in St Martin, where his mother lived illegally and worked as a housekeeper. She had fled Haiti following the coup against Aristide and the US-led embargo that made life very difficult for the poor. Aristide was restored by the US on condition that he carry out neoliberal reforms, which destroyed the rural economy. ‘It may have been good for some of my farmers in Arkansas, but it has not worked,’ Bill Clinton admitted later. ‘I have to live every day with the consequences of the lost capacity to produce a rice crop in Haiti.’

After being expelled from St Martin, D.’s mother returned to her parents’ home in southern Haiti, but they argued about her failure to repay a loan and she soon left for the Dominican Republic, again working illegally. The Dominican Republic is known for its hostility to Haitians, but she made something of a life there and when D. was about thirteen, he went to join her. He began working illegally too – his Spanish is better than his Kreyòl now. In 2017, D. decided to seek his fortune in Chile, whose government was keen to attract foreign workers at the time. He got a job in construction, then a better one laying cable and power lines. He sent money back to his mother and young son. He got an apartment, a car, a dog. But when Sebastián Piñera returned to power in 2018, visa restrictions were imposed and hundreds of Haitians were flown back to Port-au-Prince on ‘voluntary’ deportation flights.

D. stayed. He didn’t want to speak badly of Chile, ‘but we did suffer, as Haitians.’ In the summer of 2023, he gave up his lease, found someone to adopt his dog and sold his car. He travelled north to Matamoros on the proceeds. His luck seemed good. The trek – seven thousand miles by bus, ferry, foot and canoe – took him only fifteen days. He hoped to get to New York, where he had friends, Haitians he’d known in Chile, who promised to put him up in Brooklyn. He wouldn’t have attempted the journey if Trump had been in power, he told me. ‘He doesn’t want Blacks. He hates Haitians – if he is elected, he will want to return every one of them back to Haiti.’

In the US, the language of migration tends toward the hydraulic: surge, wave, pressure, influx, flood, flow. These terms cast human movement as a physical force rather than the outcome of decisions made across decades and centuries. Since 2014 it has become common for American headlines to declare an ‘unprecedented surge’ of migration at the southern border. This primed US citizens for the hysteria of Trump’s repeated assertion that ‘illegal immigration is poisoning the blood of our country.’ A poll conducted in January found that nearly half of Americans agreed.

Before the Iowa caucuses, I watched a video of an elderly Trump supporter trying to explain why ‘the immigration thing’ was of great concern to her. She patted her chest and said: ‘I’m a Christian woman, and I believe we have to help others.’ Then she sighed heavily. ‘But I don’t know what to do about that .’ The interview took place in Elk Run Heights, Iowa, where, according to 2021 data, three of the 886 residents were born outside the United States and all were naturalised citizens. The Texas border is more than a thousand miles away.

Though Americans have strong opinions about the border, few know what’s going on there. Felicia Rangel-Samponaro, who runs an organisation called the Sidewalk School, is one of those who does. The Sidewalk School operates in both Matamoros and Reynosa. At first it ran schools for children stuck at the border, employing asylum seekers as teachers; now it also provides food, shelter and legal and clinical services as well as a satellite internet service – essential for booking CBP One appointments.

On the evening of 11 May last year, as President Biden prepared to lift the Title 42 restrictions on asylum seekers, police and journalists staked out the Texas side of the border to capture the expected migrant hordes. No one appeared. Around midnight, Felicia explained to the journalists that it wasn’t in the interest of asylum seekers to rush the border, and risk deportation. ‘It’s excessive,’ she said, gesturing at the police squadrons. ‘I’m not sure why we feel there’s so much of a threat now. Who is all this for?’

Is there a ‘crisis’ at the border? Prodded repeatedly to use the word, Alejandro Mayorkas, the US secretary of homeland security, has refused. ‘The choice of language has become a proxy for the politics of the issue,’ he told a New York Times reporter in February, as House Republicans planned his impeachment. Mayorkas is right, but he might do better to admit that there are multiple border crises, and to articulate what they are. Migrants do not pose a threat to the United States. Quite the reverse: the border is unsafe for migrants.

The International Organisation for Migration describes the US-Mexico border as the world’s deadliest land crossing, with more fatalities than the Darién Gap in southern Panama. IOM recorded nearly seven hundred deaths and disappearances in 2022 and the real total must be higher (they couldn’t access data from several Texas county coroners’ offices or the Mexican search and rescue agency). In 2022, Customs and Border Protection was chastised by the Government Accountability Office for lapses in the recording of migrant deaths. It has yet to publish reports for the last two fiscal years, although internet data leaked to CBS gave a figure of 853 deaths for 2021-22.

The Biden government has called the CBP One app a success; right-wing lawmakers depict it as ‘concierge service’ for migrants. It’s really just a tech-enabled method of ‘metering’ inspections, a practice introduced by Obama in 2016 in response to growing numbers of Haitian asylum seekers, but with better optics: fewer images of huddled masses at border crossings. The app gives the CBP more control over who is inspected. A fixed number of inspections are granted each day – currently 1450 – across eight of the 48 ports of entry. The basis on which they are awarded is unclear. When I was in Mexico in September, Haitians were waiting less than a month for an appointment, but the waiting period has now reportedly increased to five or six months.

Those unable to schedule an inspection or wait for one have limited options. Some line up outside the crossings, only to be chased away by Mexican soldiers. Some cross the border between ports of entry with the intention of surrendering to Border Patrol as soon as possible. The Texas governor, Greg Abbott, has spent $10 billion on a deterrence strategy, Operation Lone Star, which includes miles of concertina wire and saw blades attached to buoys in the Rio Grande. A law permitting Texas police to arrest asylum seekers is in litigation. Border Patrol has begun operating a handful of open-air detention sites along the Californian border. There, asylum seekers are forced to wait, sometimes for days, to be processed, but are offered no medical care, sanitation or shelter. The government disputes that it is detaining anyone, and claims that the migrants are free to leave.

Much of the border is a zone of no accountability. At a children’s shelter run by the Mexican government in Tijuana, I met a ten-year-old boy, B., who had been stuck there for almost two months. His mother had been granted humanitarian parole in the US some eighteen months earlier. She had arranged for B. to fly from Haiti to Mexico and placed him in the care of a friend who agreed to help him get across the border. The friend had instead passed B. on to another person, who charged his mother $500 a month for his care. Eventually B. ran away and tried to cross the border himself. He was detained by Mexican authorities and taken to the shelter.

B. had a mobile phone but was not allowed to contact his mother. A shelter official who was present during our interview said the phone was broken, and this was the reason they hadn’t contacted his mother. B. said (in Kreyòl, which the official couldn’t understand) that his mother was on Facebook and could have been contacted there. When I spoke to her on the phone later, she told me she had been frantic with worry. Someone claiming to be a lawyer had rung her up and offered to locate her son if she paid him $1100. As soon as she wired the money, he stopped replying to her. Six weeks after B.’s disappearance, she saw a phone number for the Haitian Bridge Alliance. She called them. The Bridge and its partners scoured their networks and eventually found B. at the shelter.

I knew that M. had reached the US safely when the avatar on her WhatsApp profile changed to an American flag with a bald eagle in the foreground. She and her husband have been staying with family members in Florida. When I last spoke to her, she had applied for a work permit, but not asylum. D. arrived in New York City on the same day that the mayor, Eric Adams, warned that immigrants would destroy the city. We didn’t discuss this when I met him a month later in Flatbush, a neighbourhood in Brooklyn where many Caribbean immigrants live. D. was staying in an apartment off Nostrand Avenue, near a stretch of the street known as Toussaint L’Ouverture Boulevard. He had been surprised to discover that getting a work permit meant a long, bureaucratic process costing hundreds of dollars. He was looking – unsuccessfully – for off-the-books work and worrying about paying the rent. The house his friends from Chile had tried to secure had fallen through, but the owner had kept their deposit. In the meantime, they were renting part of a one-room apartment. The living area was partitioned by a curtain: the owner of the apartment stayed on the window side; D. got the brown fabric futon near the galley kitchen, for which he paid $250 a month. The Haitians in Flatbush were not kind to new arrivals, he said. When asked for directions, some of them pretended not to know Kreyòl – ‘even if I had just heard them speaking it on the phone’. He was already thinking about returning to Chile.

We sat on the futon and spoke about his journey. He traced his route from Santiago to Matamoros on my phone and showed me photographs of his son, still in the Dominican Republic, and of his dog in Santiago. He played a video of the ferry crossing from Necoclí in Colombia to the start of the Darién Gap. Everything was bright: the sun shone on the sea and on the faces of the passengers. They could have been on a pleasure boat.

Send Letters To:

The Editor London Review of Books, 28 Little Russell Street London, WC1A 2HN [email protected] Please include name, address, and a telephone number.

Download the LRB app

Read anywhere with the London Review of Books app , available now from the App Store for Apple devices, Google Play for Android devices and Amazon for your Kindle Fire.

Sign up to our newsletter

For highlights from the latest issue, our archive and the blog, as well as news, events and exclusive promotions.

Please enable Javascript

This site requires the use of Javascript to provide the best possible experience. Please change your browser settings to allow Javascript content to run.